I suppose talking about SF position... first of all..both of them are not good... so as long they are backups... I would choose the first one... better IS-ID, better JR and plus the experience .... but soon enough you should replace him too... he is 33 (34 in a few weeks) so he will start poping down... plus he misses many first scale skills , like reasonable OD , passing and etc...
just my two cents