BuzzerBeater Forums

Help - English > Playoff seeding tiebreakers

Playoff seeding tiebreakers

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
166078.1
Date: 12/12/2010 7:09:03 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
5959
Probably been asked, but are there any tiebreakers at all besides point differential? It'd be nice if H2H would be first, but projected spots don't suggest that :-/

This Post:
00
166078.2 in reply to 166078.1
Date: 12/12/2010 7:26:37 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
237237
Points differential is tie breaker. In the unlikely event that 2 teams have the same PD, then the team with the higher points for is ranked higher

From: j9s3

This Post:
22
166078.3 in reply to 166078.2
Date: 12/12/2010 9:09:07 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
5151
In the unlikely event that 2 teams have the same PD, then the team with the higher points for is ranked higher


This is a bogus rule. Just sayin...
They shouldnt favor better offensive teams at the cost of better defensive teams if they are equally good.

From: Coach_Gil

To: j9s3
This Post:
00
166078.5 in reply to 166078.3
Date: 12/12/2010 11:42:38 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
5555
In the unlikely event that 2 teams have the same PD, then the team with the higher points for is ranked higher


This is a bogus rule. Just sayin...
They shouldnt favor better offensive teams at the cost of better defensive teams if they are equally good.

yeah in soccer/football, during the cup contestant when there are 2 games, one in each team's home. if the sum of both games is a tie, the team that scores more in the away game gets to advance if for example you win 1-0 at home and lose 1-2 away you advance

This Post:
00
166078.6 in reply to 166078.5
Date: 12/13/2010 3:38:28 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
In the unlikely event that 2 teams have the same PD, then the team with the higher points for is ranked higher


This is a bogus rule. Just sayin...
They shouldnt favor better offensive teams at the cost of better defensive teams if they are equally good.

yeah in soccer/football, during the cup contestant when there are 2 games, one in each team's home. if the sum of both games is a tie, the team that scores more in the away game gets to advance if for example you win 1-0 at home and lose 1-2 away you advance


not only at such ko games, also in normal league.

But it isn't that unusual in absketball too, after the head to head and point differential comparison.

And head to head don't work here, cause of the one games inter conference series.

From: j9s3

This Post:
00
166078.8 in reply to 166078.6
Date: 12/13/2010 3:07:04 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
5151

And head to head don't work here, cause of the one games inter conference series.


That's why they could use conference records instead of head to head. And why wouldn't head to head work? Each team plays 2 games with each team in its conference. So in the case of a team winning 2-0, head to head should work.
A one game tiebreaker could work too.

From: CrazyEye

To: j9s3
This Post:
00
166078.10 in reply to 166078.8
Date: 12/13/2010 3:18:29 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959

And head to head don't work here, cause of the one games inter conference series.


That's why they could use conference records instead of head to head. And why wouldn't head to head work? Each team plays 2 games with each team in its conference. So in the case of a team winning 2-0, head to head should work.
A one game tiebreaker could work too.


a one game tie breaker would be in most cases the home team, if you compare teams of the same strength. And this draw is mostly random, which isn't the best solution i think.

And i don't like so many special rules, so that wouldn't like a rule which handles interconference tie breaks different then conference tie breaks.

And if we get head to head, i want another end game logic too ;)

This Post:
44
166078.11 in reply to 166078.7
Date: 12/13/2010 3:36:35 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
5151
The rule is standard and is typically applied as a second tiebreaker in most sports.


Sorry, this is not true (At least for the US, I dont know what sports they play in bulgaria...)

In football (American football), head-to-head is the first tiebreaker, then division records, then common games, then conference records. In the case of BB, the "divisions" are the "conferences", because BB doesnt divide the conferences by locations (east, north, south, etc.). The teams' net points (total points scored) do not come into play until the 9th tiebreaker.

In baseball, for a division tie, they use head-to-head first, then intradivision games, then higher winning percentage in the last half of the season, then the winning percentage in the last half of the season +1 game, last half +2 games, etc.
For a wildcard, a tiebreaker game is used.
Runs scored are not even considered in this tiebreaker.

For basketball, it is H2H, then division record, conference record, record against teams that qualified for playoffs, points differential.
Again, net points are not considered in the tiebreaker either.

These are the three major/most popular/most competitive team sports in the US, and from high school (and below) to professional level, tiebreakers rarely involve net points, because it unfairly favors the better offensive team.
From my experience (I've played four team sports competitively, H2H, division records, and one game playoffs have always decided a tiebreaker for the postseason.)
As for BB, the closest comparison is the NBA (being basketball), which does not consider total points for tiebreakers. If they did, if teams like the Spurs or Celtics faced this situation, they would be unfairly screwed over.