To be honest, I don't think it matters, he's better than you & your not even at full strength. Play TIE & grab extra Enthusiasm points.
If I was you & wanted to try to win, then I'd look at Low Post M2M, with either my best Driver or 3rd best Inside Shooter at the 3. 2-3 Zone is a bad Defense period, in my opinion, it gives up way too much Outside Offense, makes a bad out side shooting team look half decent.
Looks like he's played Normal all season & you have TIE'd a few. Playing Normal would help you a lot.
Right is not a popularity contest!