BuzzerBeater Forums

BB USA > U21 National Team Debate Thread

U21 National Team Debate Thread (thread closed)

Set priority
Show messages by
From: oriolekid

This Post:
00
276706.105 in reply to 276706.67
Date: 2/17/2016 12:27:50 PM
LionPride
III.11
Overall Posts Rated:
246246
Of course I'll find the time. I've always found the time. It seems like every day since December 21st, 2009, since I was a Freshman in high school, I've found the time. My time every day need naught be recorded on the offsite. I have scouted, I have gameplanned, I have discussed their build(see: Cliff Duncan), I have trained(see: Otto Reedy). I haven't had a reason to make sure everyone is doing their jobs since that should be reserved for their coach, but I obviously will when it comes down to it. I've offered advice when people have PMed me.

Jelme, Wozzt, Jfarb, Edju, Namssor, RamQ, Sleet have all been great BB managers, and attribute great things to the NT, most have even been BB managers. None are still active. All have been qualified. I've learned from most of them. I've even taught some of them.

My experience is extremely strong. I've stuck through this game for so many year, and have seen hundreds of great managers go. I was one of the original scouters, back when only the NT/U21 coach did it. I volunteered my time and now dozens of managers scout for us. I have the oldest training diary on the offsite. I keep it update, still.

I'm qualified for this job. Isaiah, finally, got his NT job. I think it'd be poetic if I joined him this season with my own job. Though, he's still never won an election, which I find even more beautiful.

This Post:
00
276706.106 in reply to 276706.105
Date: 2/17/2016 12:34:24 PM
Smallfries
III.1
Overall Posts Rated:
417417
Second Team:
Smallfries II
Hey now...I did win an election http://www.buzzerbeater.com/country/1/ntelection.aspx?ele...

But that would be very poetic.

This Post:
00
276706.107 in reply to 276706.106
Date: 2/17/2016 1:46:17 PM
LionPride
III.11
Overall Posts Rated:
246246
Ahh you had to go spoil the history and, you know, win. How dare you!

From: FurY

This Post:
00
276706.108 in reply to 276706.95
Date: 2/17/2016 2:31:55 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
109109
Alright all....back to the debate.

My question for all- there can be a fine line between training for the U21 and training for the NT. Sometimes, training for the NT can mean that players wont necessarily be great options for the U21 because of getting the out of position training early on. As manager, will you be willing to work with myself, and any other possible future NT manager, if that means some of your best young talent wont be options for the U21?

Also, to go along with the question above, typically the Scouts are in charge of the players 21 years old and younger. As the NT manager, I typically work with guys in the 22-32 years range and even had some amazing help with the 22-25 years range last season. Due to rarely working with U21 players, how will you determine which ones go the NT route compared to U21? Do you plan to make this a conversation between myself and you, plan to make that decision yourself, or plan to make that a community decision?


I'm not of the belief that the majority of the NT players are not of use to the u21, and vice versa. The players that i want to incorporate into the u21 are involved in less prominent roles, and probably less potential than is desired for the u21 group. I'd also point out that the majority of Phyr's ideal builds that he posted for the NT builds, whether or not they are accurate, are entirely doable within a u21 run as well.

In reality to go with your 2nd question, it's up to the user who owns that player first. Only then can i send a BB-mail and say "is this guy someone on your radar or no" to someone like you currently if i can get the buy-in required, or get them to sell to someone who will.

From: FurY

This Post:
00
276706.109 in reply to 276706.103
Date: 2/17/2016 2:46:51 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
109109
First, Goldbear has applied, as has O-kid. So there are four people making the effort still, not just two. I haven't known goldbear for much other than the occasional trollings in the US-chat, and i've seen oriole kid around quite a few times.

With regards to what i bring, i'm more focused on player builds, one on one approaches, and most importantly opposition scouting. I feel that in most cases I can understand what my opponents move is going to be in the basketball sim (with regards to the actual games and the decisions that go into them). I don't think i would stop trying to do that if i lost, especially if it's tough. While we have two different approaches to the game, i only ever get frustrated with him when he tries to firesale his own buzzerbeater team haha.

The u21 lacks the ability to get to the 15/15/12/8 build by the time the u21 season rolls around on most of the talent. We're going to have to be heavily resourceful to get results better than what Phyr managed, which is why i think i favor a few different types of builds. Most notably, one of our talents could be a very useful defender that matches closer to aaron's ID/SB build, and it's as good a time as any to see if a balanced SB/ID work as he'll be amongst the top players available I feel for the u21 team as far as bigs go in season 35. This season shouldn't be awful.

I favor higher SB and slightly lower Rebounding on bigs, especially if we are to only get to 12 REB. the 12 SB is much more effective in conjuction with a high defense. My guess is the formula behind the shots has something to do with the defensive position (ID or OD based calculations) before it calculates a blocked shot. A big with a somewhat high secondary in OD (thinking 7 OD honestly, the top end of what the player can get without training) and good ID/SB (14/13 or 15/12 ID/SB) with good IS will do well enough. Additionally, i feel that SB and ID training promote better training speeds for one another, which would not harm the ability to get the most points possible.

Josh

From: Isaiah

To: FurY
This Post:
00
276706.110 in reply to 276706.108
Date: 2/17/2016 3:02:56 PM
Smallfries
III.1
Overall Posts Rated:
417417
Second Team:
Smallfries II
Hypothetical question to all:

Someone comes to you with a 6'11" big man(HOF potential) with these starting skills: 6/3/3/4/4/5-6/6/7/6

This owner is really excited about this player but has little experience training. How would you go about discussing with this manager the correct way to go about training? What build style would you aim for for this player if I, the NT manager, also think he could be useful for the NT at a later point?

From: Nick22

To: FurY
This Post:
00
276706.111 in reply to 276706.109
Date: 2/17/2016 3:29:11 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
8888
First, Goldbear has applied, as has O-kid. So there are four people making the effort still, not just two. I haven't known goldbear for much other than the occasional trollings in the US-chat, and i've seen oriole kid around quite a few times.

That's my bad, I hadn't seen a speech from either and in O-kid's case, his posts here were buried. Fixed it.

This Post:
00
276706.112 in reply to 276706.109
Date: 2/17/2016 3:34:48 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
9999
First, Goldbear has applied, as has O-kid. So there are four people making the effort still, not just two. I haven't known goldbear for much other than the occasional trollings in the US-chat, and i've seen oriole kid around quite a few times.


For one, it's GOLDMEMBEAR. And sorry we haven't had a chance to meet sport. But it's apparent we don't frequent the same locales.

I can not believe this is actually the U21 election.



Last edited by GOLDMEMBEAR at 2/17/2016 3:35:24 PM

This Post:
00
276706.113 in reply to 276706.110
Date: 2/17/2016 3:45:42 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
9999
Hypothetical question to all:

Someone comes to you with a 6'11" big man(HOF potential) with these starting skills: 6/3/3/4/4/5-6/6/7/6

This owner is really excited about this player but has little experience training. How would you go about discussing with this manager the correct way to go about training? What build style would you aim for for this player if I, the NT manager, also think he could be useful for the NT at a later point?


For starters, you point every enthusiastic new manager to the BB Bible by RIP. Have them memorize it. In the end it is up to them, but if they want help then you fill needs. They are the ones adding value to their respective teams. You can only show them the door.

This Post:
11
276706.114 in reply to 276706.103
Date: 2/17/2016 5:49:19 PM
LionPride
III.11
Overall Posts Rated:
246246
I will bring very little if I don't win. Sure, not popular, but I have now lost like 8-9 elections now, and it's not for a lack of trying. I was an advanced scout, I was the head scout, I did participate in gameplanning. I've done it all. And it netted me absolutely nothing. Why would continuing to work under people and then have another candidate come out of nowhere, who did much less than me but had the right people backing him, win?

I'll do what I've always done. Answer questions directed at me, look over training guides and give advice. But I'm not subjecting myself to another season of vigorous scouting. Unless I win.

I wouldn't be opposed to calling up the less potentialed, but more talented players if it helped the team win. The U21 coaches objective is to win first, care about the NT second. I'd rather us be a powerhouse U21 team, or NT team(I mean, both is good, too) than above average in both. So yes, I'd do what it took to make the team win. If the trainers come to me about NT plan, I'll direct them to the NT coach. That's been a major issue in the past about the U21 coach giving the trainers NT builds that the NT coach did not 100% agree with.

The end game is winning.

I started up the training diary thread. It fell dormant for over a year, and in the very beginning, it wasn't really a forum for team training. I was the first one to document my week to week progress. Then Wozzt jumped on board, and then more did. But I was the first, and now it is the single most popular forum for training advice, and sharing.

I have other minor ones that are probably better than others best claim, but that right there, listed above, changed the entire offsite forum for the better. It would not be where it is today if I hadn't started the training diaries up.

This Post:
00
276706.115 in reply to 276706.114
Date: 2/17/2016 6:03:57 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
199199
My question for all candidates:

A lot of the U21 team being good is luck of having good draft seasons and dedicated managers getting the best trainees. How do you account for the variance this causes and what do you think (other than just offering up specific builds) is the best way to get ahead of the curve in training compared to the rest of the world?

Secondly, what type of gameplan and training analysis have you done and its cause on team play? Do you have databases or historical data for this information that you could utilize to the advantage of the U21 team?

Last edited by Coach_Nuggets at 2/17/2016 6:04:26 PM

Advertisement