BuzzerBeater Forums

BB USA > Your Top 10 best NBA players

Your Top 10 best NBA players

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
11
152411.11 in reply to 152411.10
Date: 7/24/2010 4:06:08 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
143143
That is what I meant by old (Games played,years,wear & tear on the body) but thanks for pointing that out.

Garry Muir
This Post:
00
152411.12 in reply to 152411.1
Date: 7/25/2010 3:48:26 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
I'll go by if I drafted them today (which takes into consideration age, injury tendencies, etc., but not salary - value)

1. Kevin Durant (he's so young and such a good scorer. So long and I think his potential is too good to pass up).
2. LeBron (still young, and obviously a great player. We'll see how things work out with Miami. It may end up bringing out the best in LeBron during the playoffs when they play the best teams, but that is at the expense of watching him being amazing for 82 regular season games. Now I think he coasts through 50 regular season games.)
3. Kobe (he'd be #1 if he were in his early to mid 20s. He's got the killer mentality and will play hard for 82 games and then take it up a notch during the playoffs).
4. Howard (the best center in the league. He's not a great offensive player but team him with a great point and shooters and he can be a very dangerous scorer. Plus the league's best big defender).
5. Chris Paul (the best point guard in the league. And still young. His injury is a bit of a concern and his current team won't get him enough important games. But team him with Howard and the Magic have an edge on the Heat.)
6. Wade (I think he's great. Just a little older and a little more fragile than the above.)
7. Melo (a natural scorer and proven winner - won a NCAA championship almost single handedly. A bit crazy but the talent is too good to pass up)
8. Derrick Rose (young and super quick. I think he'll get much better in the near future.)
9. Amare (not a great defensive player, but such a dynamic scorer for a power forward. Injury history is a concern and can't carry a team by himself, but I think not too difficult to build around).
10.Can't decide between Rondo or Curry. Rondo is a dynamic defensive guard but his shooting is terrible. Will he get better? I think so, but maybe never above average. Curry is the opposite. A great offensive player with unbelievable range and great shooting percentages for a guard but a below average defender.

This Post:
11
152411.13 in reply to 152411.12
Date: 7/25/2010 6:51:22 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
143143
I know I will sound like a homer with this, but what about D-Will, I think he could replace 2 or maybe 3 of thos guys on your list, but like I said I am probably to big of a homer.

Garry Muir
From: Jason

This Post:
00
152411.14 in reply to 152411.13
Date: 7/25/2010 7:09:39 PM
Arizona Desert Storm
III.3
Overall Posts Rated:
11181118
What a freaking Homer!!! LOL

:D

This Post:
00
152411.15 in reply to 152411.13
Date: 7/25/2010 7:33:38 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
Definitely a great player. Thought about him, but a little older than Rose, Rondo and Curry. Not far outside the top 10, but I personally prefer these 10/11 right now.

This Post:
00
152411.16 in reply to 152411.15
Date: 7/25/2010 7:48:05 PM
Arizona Desert Storm
III.3
Overall Posts Rated:
11181118
I personally would take D Williams over all of those guys...but that is based on today...give it a couple of years and those guys have better long term potential...but as far as a guy to lead my team this coming season? If not Nash, I would go with D Williams.

This Post:
00
152411.17 in reply to 152411.16
Date: 7/25/2010 9:34:08 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
If it's for just this season, then I'd go with Nash and Williams also. But based on my conditions of getting them for this year and having their rights for the future, I'll still go with my choices.

This Post:
00
152411.18 in reply to 152411.1
Date: 7/26/2010 2:20:06 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
1515
My top ten (counting down =D)

10. Rajon Rondo. Sure the guy's been out-shined by Pierce, Garnett, and Allen in the past, but last season, the guy lead the team to the NBA finals, pending injury to Garnett. He's really impressed me this past season; I may not like the Celtics, but he's the greatest Celtic I've seen play the game since Larry Byrd.

9. Deron Williams. He's got the desire to win, and the heart. He puts forth the effort that impresses me, and he's great in the playoffs. He may not be deserving of this spot, but I'll give it to him- he's got the props to take it.

8. Chris Bosh. He's a great power forward who can shoot and rebound to nearly the level of Dirk; my only fear is that he won't shine as brightly with Dwayne and LeBron to take the shots with him.

7. Dirk Nowitzki. He's a great big man, he can rebound the ball, drive the lane, pass well, and he can shoot the three ball. How many power forwards can do that as well as he can? Not many, that's for sure. I feel he's more than deserving of this spot not only for his stats, but for his desire to win and for the effort; he always seems to give it 110%.

6. Steve Nash. He's the best distributor in the game, he can shoot, and he can drive the lane. He's an excellent player, but with Stoudemire off to New York, I feel the number of assists may suffer to his shooting; Phoenix just doesn't have the supporting cast to get him the assists now, in my opinion.

5. Dwayne Wade. I would love to say he's above Dwight, but I just feel that he's not as good as we think. He's still young, but his best year IMO was the year he lead the Heat to a title. Shaq left, and he was never quite as good IMO. Now that he's got LeBron and Chris Bosh aside him, I think his stats may dip even more by sharing the ball with the other two future Hall of Famers that signed this offseason, but if he manages to pull of a season like he has, he'll be above Dwight.

4. Dwight Howard. He may likely be at the end of his career the best big man the game's ever seen; better than Shaq, perhaps even better than Hakeem. He lead the Magic this past season, and he's on his A-Game every time out.

3. Kevin Durant. More than likely too high on the list, but I feel that with his scoring ability, and with the show he put on with the kind of supporting cast he has in Oklahoma City, he's more than deserving of this spot.

2. LeBron James. James is probably a more effective player than Kobe, but his supporting cast was too ineffective until his signing with Miami to make it show; if his stats remain the way they are even with the Heat, I'll put him number one, but I think that with Bosh and D-Wade, his stats will dip a bit. Also, lack of success in the playoffs takes away from my thoughts of him.

1. Kobe Bryant. Kobe Bryant is at least number two here, but I think that his success in the playoffs and that his stats still are as good as they are with the cast around him all able to score big is what puts him ahead of LeBron.

Some others that might've made the cut that didn't:

Chris Paul. He's a great Point Guard, but after injury last season, I'm not sure he'll do his best in the upcoming year; a wrestling term to describe this is "ring rust", when a wrestler doesn't fight for a while for any one of various reasons, and then doesn't fight 100% of his ability in his first few matches back.

Carmelo Anthony. He's good, but the thought on my mind is, how good? I feel he may be past his prime by a bit.

Tim Duncan. Let's face it; he's getting old.

Chauncey Billups. He's good, you can't argue it.

Vince Carter. To be honest, this is more from a fan's point of view. He played well last season with the magic, and in his prime up in Toronto, he would've made the top 5, but he's getting old, so I'm not putting him on the list.


Edited to add on Vince Carter in "those who didn't make the cut" list.

Last edited by clubcool at 8/8/2010 4:52:26 PM

From: Royaleis

This Post:
00
152411.19 in reply to 152411.7
Date: 7/27/2010 4:43:52 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
Shaq
Kobe
Lebron
Melo
Dwade
Durant
Manu
Derrick
Rondo

This Post:
00
152411.20 in reply to 152411.1
Date: 7/28/2010 1:44:03 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
22
1. Lebron
2. Kobe
3. D-Wade
4. D Rose
5. Steve Nash
6. Dirk Nowitzki
7. KG
8. D Williams
9. Rajon Rhondo
10. Gasol


This Post:
11
152411.21 in reply to 152411.20
Date: 7/30/2010 5:05:52 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
4343
I feel like you guys don't give enough credit to Gasol...IMO he's currently the best PF in the game right now...I can accept if you think Nowitzki is better because he has a much better long range shot, but Chris Bosh being better than Gasol is a joke...

Advertisement