Mostly win win, but not always.
Pro:
1. Higher exp. is always good.
2. You can pick guys with higher exp. real cheap cuz they are generally old.
Con:
1. Cuz they are old, they can drop in skills.
But weighting the overall pros and cons, I am a huge supporter of guys with higher exp. I used to be afraid of the skill drops, but now I understand the drops are mainly negligible
Anyway, I'm just picking out faults. I guess you could call it a win win
"Falling in love is not at all the most stupid thing that people do but gravitation cannot be held responsible for it."