BuzzerBeater Forums

BB Global (English) > The Foul System in BB

The Foul System in BB

Set priority
Show messages by
From: Veoz

This Post:
00
313451.14 in reply to 313451.13
Date: 1/24/2022 7:09:32 AM
Aubel Nation
BBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
3131
Second Team:
Sclessin Fever
If the issue is that aggressive players get fouled out too quickly in competitive games, the easy solution is to use "sit them" instead of "let them play" and they'll play 25-30' in most games.


Except that it's not realistic at all. BB is meant to be realistic, as realistic as it can in terms of GE.
Take player X who plays for team Y in NBA (real world). In a given game, he has 3 fouls in the first quarter. He gets benched then plays again in Q2 and, hopefully he calmed down and will still be able to play in Q3 and Q4 if needed. This makes total sense.

In BB, some of the most aggressive players will be benched, then play again in Q2, make one more foul, which will send them back to the bench, and he'll most likely make one more foul in Q3 before being sent out in Q4. Total minutes played could very well be under 20 even though he got benched, and this is because under the current GE, aggressive players do not adapt at all, which is pure nonsense.

My point is, with a very aggressive players you have the two following options :

1) "sit them" and he'll eventually foul out late in the game, after playing like 20 minutes
2) "let them play" and he'll foul out after 20 minutes, that is, in the middle of Q2

Neither of these options make any sense, specifically when you consider the fact that aggressive players foul out early in the game repeatedly.

From: Veoz

This Post:
22
313451.17 in reply to 313451.16
Date: 1/25/2022 1:37:59 AM
Aubel Nation
BBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
3131
Second Team:
Sclessin Fever
My evidence is that my starting C fouled out 7 times in 36 games last season, which is 20% of his games.

Does that make sense to you? Is it realistic?

Basically I can assume that he won’t be able to finish one game out of five. That’s not a basketball player, that’s a serial killer.

This Post:
11
313451.21 in reply to 313451.6
Date: 1/25/2022 10:30:03 AM
white snake
II.1
Overall Posts Rated:
72437243
Second Team:
Black Forest Boars
That's the point. When a player is in fouls trouble he should play much less well defensively to avoid more fouls (that doesn't mean he won't make fouls anymore).

Isn't this the case already? After a player receives his fifth foul, his defende goes down and he plays less aggressive. I always thought, this is Part of the engine. I will check my files, if I can find something about it.

This Post:
00
313451.22 in reply to 313451.19
Date: 1/25/2022 12:42:57 PM
Lion Rules Again
IV.19
Overall Posts Rated:
1313
If I put ‘let them play’ the probability of being foul out is higher in your esperience?

I always put ‘let them play’ to optimize my training and today in a useless match against a bot my trainee goes out in 24 minutes….

Perhaps sit them is a better choice?

Advertisement