Lagana - 79 minutes - mediocre game shape (same as above)
This is laughable.
Lagana played 79 minutes that week, 83 the week before, 62 the week before that, 68 minutes the week before that, and finally 72 the week before that.
I have been playing since Season 2, and there is simply no way that a player can drop to MEDIOCRE game shape with perfect minutes for three straight weeks and then two weeks with minutes that are SLIGHTLY above the optimum unless a)there was a bug or b)the game shape formula has changed.
Also,
Knobeler - 80 minutes - average game shape (80 minutes definitely lowers your GS)
: the bolded part in this statement is just a flat out lie. If you want I can keep track of the shape of all players before and after a training update in which they have 80 or above minutes, and I can prove to you that it is not 100% sure that 80 or more minutes lowers game shape. Again, I say this with absolute certainty since I've been playing since season 2, so I've been around for quite a few updates.
And while I'm at it,
Mühlestein - 71 minutes - proficient game shape (that's ok, right?)
: perhaps it would have been worth mentioning that he only played 9 minutes in the Private League game that was causing the problem, so his total for the week was 80 minutes, which, unlike you incorrectly stated, does NOT guarantee that game shape will drop.
And we can go on:
Abraão - 69 minutes - strong (again, nothing wrong)
...yes, definitely nothing wrong, even though you fail to mention that he only played 7 minutes in the incriminated PL match, which brings his total to a more than acceptable 76 minutes. So just like the previous player, this proves absolutely nothing.
And on we go...
Avagliano - 75 minutes - average game shape (can't expect 75 minutes to raise the GS, can you?)
: Yes, we could actually expect it since it happens week in and week out to many players. What we can't expect is that a player that plays 75 minutes one week, 77 the week before, 63 the week before that, and 68 the week before that finds himself with average game shape. Which of those two scenarios is more likely? I would have to say the first one, right? However, if you factor in the 39 minutes he played in that Private League match, his total for the week rises to 114 minutes, which would more than justify a collapse in game shape.
The starting lineup for Campania Rats's Private League match was the following:
Knobeler, Avagliano, Bartolomei, Claverini, Laganà. All those players played a minimum of 39 minutes. Their game shape is respectively average, average, respectable, respectable, and mediocre.
If you want to keep pretending that there is no problem, fine, you are free to do so. Just know that anyone who has even the slightest bit of experience in this game can see that either this is not the case or the user suffered by far the worst luck in game shape that I have ever seen in the 10+seasons I have been playing.
Maybe it would have been better to just admit there was a problem, admit that it was not solvable, and advise against playing PL games before or during the weekly update.