BuzzerBeater Forums

(7492282)

536k

Didn't remember about him, thanks

Well first of all hi, my name is yoav and I'm training this team since season 32, at season 43 I've managed to get up to the first league in Israel after selling a 22 yo player with 153k salary for 3.6 m ((43863576))
At that point I chose to buy amichai shalev as a trainer, I saw him for sale for 2.5m and after a bid war I bought him for 3.2m. The first season in the first league I've managed to stay but last season I lost 2-1 in the relegation series. This season I'm back to the second league and hoping to get back to the first
Now for some facts, I've played with amichai shalev as a PG most of my games at the first league and won some of them ((104759827) , (104759867)) and even the last game I placed amichai as my PG and got a win ((105997759))

Last thing I want to say is that you said some really offensive stuff about me and how I'm managing my team. You're saying that I'm a farm, although just last season I've paid over 600k for salaries each week trying to be as competitive as I can
I would be more than happy if you'll erase all of your accuses of me doing illegal stuff
thanks

Wow, You are a rude person.

I wrote this message in Hebrew since you don't seem to comprehend when you read in your own mother tongue, so didn't see why to bother. And, well, Google translate is always there. I admit I didn't know it's forbidden, don't use the global forums often and apologize for that.

Anyway, I was wondering where the coach of a medium community with pretty mediocre teams, who have never achieved one serious achievement at the level of national or young teams find the pretence to criticize the way other communities are run. On what right do you say that the coach of our young team is lying to the coaches so that they will hurt themselves economically? In what right do you call Israeli teams farms without a shred of proof, because they chose to run in a different way from yours?

So first of all, thank you for your advice. However, we are doing quite well in managing our community. I think we are doing a nice job on this subject, which can be seen mainly in the youth team with whom we won a bronze medal in the World Championship. Remind me when England reached a similar achievement?

The coach of our youth team and I have full coordination regarding the training of young players relevant to the youth but also the potential for the National team. In most cases, the National team and long-term needs precede the needs of the youth team. In some cases we choose to combine and in some cases, relatively rare, we decide to focus on the needs of the youth team. We do this when we look at the ceiling of the contribution that the player can reach in the national team compared to how much he can contribute to the youth team. If we see a player whose best case would be a complementary player on the national team and could be a monster in the youth team, we prefer to focus on the latter. It may be a mistake, but it is certainly not an illegitimate decision.

Your economical claims also don't have a solid basis: Trying to give a new coach the chance to train a 2.24 cm player for years at the point guard to give him better secondary skills is almost certainly a recipe for failure. The chance that he will be able to develop a relevant player is lower than the chance that he will retire from the game. Training primaries is easy, rewarding and working, and in the end, also brings in nice money when the player is ready. Not crazy, but if you're a new player and you've come up to the point where you sell the big men you trained for 4-seasons who played for the youth team -It's already a win since it means we added another player to the buzzerbeater community. I don't know about you in England, but in Israel, we fight for each user trying to keep the game alive.

BTW, I see you were very troubled with the fact I violited the rules by writing in Hebrew. I wonder, is calling other players cheaters in the forums without proof is a legal action? Or the rules just don't apply to you?

Last edited by Bill_tipesh at 5/15/2019 4:19:18 AM

I would be more than happy if you'll erase all of your accuses of me doing illegal stuff

why would I? Let's recap what happened:
1. You sell your player for 3.6 million
2 Exactly 3 days later you buy your current trainee from the utopia farm team of another Israeli manager for almost the same money
3. S44 you train primaries and win a relegation battle
4. S45 realise the player will probably not make the NT with 1 PA and low OD, train out of position (1 player) and demote

I will go as far as saying that you are not a farm team like the team you bought from (which is the team who trained for the U21 and is most likely a farm), but you surely you can understand how that sewuence of events (1 and 2 and their timing) may look suspicious. As I said, I can't see the bid history to validate your claim that it was a competitive auction against another (non Israeli) manager or the opposite, that's a GM's job. However you should understand how this can look suspicious from a neutral perspective. Especially in light of how you folks came through in this forum (having a 'system' in place where managers take a hit to train primaries first to the benefit of the U21 and then move the players to other managers who take an even larger hit to train secondaries later on).

I'll tell you something else. If someone convinced you to train this 7'3'' guy out of position at 24 you should probably take it up with him/her. Right now you are paying 160k (35%-40%) of your salary to play this player at PG, producing like a 30k player even by switching him on defense. After all he did start with 1 PA.

Sure you may end up in the playoffs and win, but it still doesnt change the fact you'd have been better off selling this guy and paying a 30k player to play pg for you. Especially if he doesnt make the NT. You would have saved 1.6m in salary per season.




Last edited by Lemonshine at 5/14/2019 8:23:55 PM

Damn phone and micro buttons: I accidentally deleted my own message trying to edit.

Apparently the head of the Ponzi scheme is so arrogant and above the rules that he decided to post on global forums in some incomprehensible dialect which is something explicitly forbidden in the game manual.

I will rewrite my advice to new users and in particular new Israeli users. There are many reasons (lower salary, lower handicap when training out of position, elastics and secondary training, no risk of accidental capping etc) to train secondaries first. Read training guides also from other nations and understand how training works on your own. Don't just assume some people in some communities have your best interests at heart. If you make a decision to burn cash to benefit your U21 and NT, you're welcome to, but do it based on knowledge and your own reasoning, not someone else's agenda

Last edited by Lemonshine at 5/14/2019 8:41:16 PM

I was wondering where the coach of a medium community with pretty mediocre teams,

You have a bigger userbase and garbage track record of success in B3, much worse than England (3-1 ko teams in the last 5 season 4-3 in the last 10). Bold words coming from a community with more mediocre teams than England. Next

Remind me when England reached a similar achievement?

We don't have a farm system and I would always be opposed to having a farming system in this game. Setting a collective achievement (for the U21!!!) by pushing the boundaries is simply a reflection of your mediocrity as managers individually. At least the Germans do or have tried to do this for their NT, which is a more natural and reasonable endeavour, without most of the negative effects your system produces. Next.

In what right do you call Israeli teams farms without a shred of proof, because they chose to run in a different way from yours?

That's what they are called: teams with the sole or main purpose of training salary monsters for the NT. Typically each farm ends up owning 1 player only because the salary is too big. These are non competitive teams in 90% of their BB life. Next.

It may be a mistake, but it is certainly not an illegitimate decision.

Finally you say something sensible. You lot you could have just said this from the beginning, but the level of hypocrisy and arrogance in your community seems to have no bounds, so you needed me to go to this length in order to admit it.
You are effectively saying if the NT/U21 staff think a player may only have an outside chance of playing in the NT, then you ask the user to train him in a way that is uneconomical and will guarantee the player will never play in the NT. Congratulations for coming out.

I will point out that you started a 114 TSP C at PF with 6 OD and 6 PA 2 JR against Spain. This is the kind of player you are saying should be ruined because he has an outside chance to make the NT (at best).

Trying to give a new coach the chance to train a 2.24 cm player for years at the point guard to give him better secondary skills is almost certainly a recipe for failure.

And yet you asked the other manager to train the PA of his 160k guy at 24yo because with 1 PA he would be unplayable. Now, if the original farm team did that at 18yo for half the time, now that player would have higher passing than he does, a slightly lower salary and would now be trained at a position where he belongs.

Any rational user would make a training plan for his player. He would check how much secondary training he can do before starting on the primaries. A 7'0''+ HoF player will indeed cap anyway after his primary training, unless you spend so long on secondaries that you won't make it in time. So it's a matter of timing. And planning.

Training primaries is easy, rewarding and working, and in the end, also brings in nice money when the player is read

Monoskilled players with bad secondaries don't sell well and cost a lot in salary. 100k for a season is 1.4 million, plus coach, plus youth trainer, plus gym which takes the cost to at least 180k. More if you train with a lvl 6 trainer. That's $2.5m per season minimum. After you spent that much money for seasons you end up selling for a fraction of your cost. The guy training the 24yo big man out with no PA at PG is paying something similar (160k+ trainer). I wonder if he realises that.

I don't know about you in England, but in Israel, we fight for each user trying to keep the game alive.

Yes and you seem to do this by providing misleading information to those users. A surefire recipe for success down the line!

I prefer suggesting users train the right way and try to succeed in the game. If you have a problem with training being too slow then take it up with Marin, but giving bad and misleading advice to further your own NT/U21 agenda is not good for user retention and people enjoying the game in the long ru

BTW, I see you were very troubled with the fact I violited the rules by writing in Hebrew. I wonder, is calling other players cheaters in the forums without proof is a legal action? Or the rules just don't apply to you?

I wasn't troubled, I thought it was fitting for the type of character you guys seem to be. I reported you for it and I'm surprised that nobody took action for so many hours.

I didn't accuse anyone of cheating, I would report the users involved if I thought there was enough proof of cheating. I simply stated the facts of what happened and said I have no way to check who was involved now. My take is that you should understand if someone thinks it's suspicious considering the general context of the system you Israeli have. Like everything that happens when a network of farms is involved (i.e. farms are not illegal, of course, but weird transactions between them may be).

In the past I reported managers and users from micronations because they passed each other money through trash players so that they were able to move their own U21 players among themselves. If you want me to formally report this instance and keep an eye on weird 'coincidences' like the one above, I'll be happy to.

Of course, you're free to report me for Cheating accusations on forums through the appropriate channel and we shall see where we get to with that.

Last edited by Lemonshine at 5/15/2019 5:45:17 AM

All I can tell you to summarize all your posts here is that I kindly reccommend you to revaluate your positions or at least reexamine your attitude towards other users and communities.

Have a nice day.

All I can tell you to summarize all your posts here is that I kindly reccommend you to revaluate your positions or at least reexamine your attitude towards other users and communities.

And I kindly recommend you to tell your NT and U21 managers, members of your community, to stop misleading new users for their gain. Will have to agree to disagree, there is no upside in discussing with arrogant people who made no solid rational arguments.

Irrational or demonstrably false points made here above include:
- High salary players with no secondary training will help you win in your league (let's take a poll, but you just need to look at the B3 winner to see this is demonstrably false)
- It is rewarding for a new manager to see skills grow (what about paying a big salary and crippling their economy, little money for competing or expanding the arena?)
- You will sell monoskilled players for a lot of $$$ (don't buy this, I have enough experience to know I need to see this happen in an auction to believe it. Currently a former Hungarian U21 starter with 23 IS and $163k salary is on the TL for $2.75m, let's see how that ends and let's see how the other 2 22yo pllayers with $100k+ salary end later today)
- You should listen to the community and give up on training a player to be the best he can for yourself and instead train for the U21 and guarantee he will never be as good as he can be (ykes)
- Training secondaries on a 7'0''+ player is useless (this is either ignorant or misleading. I already explained big men may not need DR and HA but PA and OD are another matter entirely. PA is also unaffected by height, so there is absolutely no reason not to train it. OD is slow but you are still better off training it as much as you can, as long as you still cap the player)

I don't have a problem with other communities. I have a problem with your community, the farm system that has emerged in this thread and the fact that you sell it to new managers with misleading information.





Last edited by Lemonshine at 5/15/2019 7:53:49 AM

Your "recap" of Yoav's actions are just your own interpretation made to fit your outrages claims from before, so I'd like to do a recap of my own.

You made 2 statements in your first comment:
1. "Monoskilled players do not sell well on the market"
2. "Nobody will train a 100k+ salary monoskilled player out of position"

Actually there was a third false statement about managers in Israel recommending having 6/7 trainers plus facilities, not only is that ridiculous because you don't need facilities or high level trainers for a monoskilled player, but Alon also clarified that wasn't case yet you still insist on having them as part of your "calculation" of how much it costs to train in your latest comment. whatever, on to the main dish.

Yoav pretty much destroyed both of these statements, but let's go back a bit before that. First, Alon showed you that monoskilled players do sell well, he provided one example which you dismissed as some kind of conspiracy because he was bought by an Israeli team, but when Yoav showed you one of his players was sold (for even more money) to a team in Macau and told you that the Israeli player had a bidding war over him you make up an even crazier conspiracy about Israeli team inflating the price, needless to say, backed up by zero evidence. And the player sold to Macau? Not even mentioned by you, probably because it doesn't fit with your conspiracy. No matter how to try and spin it, your statement about monoskilled players not selling well was just wrong.

Next, Yoav showed that you can train a high salary player out of position and still be competitive, but that doesn't fit your way of running a team in BB, because it's not as efficient. I mean, if you want to play the most efficient game, why not sell your entire team, buy a cheap lvl 4 coach, train a bunch of cheap trainees, sell them after 4-5 season and repeat for about 4 cycles until you have insane amounts of money, then just buy the best players, have a crazy payroll and start winning titles? probably because that would make the game boring as hell. well, some people like to see their NT/U21 (or their players in the NT) succeed just as much as their own team. I know our community is like that, maybe the English community is different and people only care about their own team. "To each their own, I guess".