Good players in my div 4 league are the ones that score consistently. You would need 2-4 pops in JS and passing, and more pops in handling. Good teams in my div4 league, though, are the ones that have players that can play defense. Try popping OD a few times before working on scoring would be my suggestion.
Check out Conrad Yanez. He is one of the top scorers in USA, but his team barely made the playoffs.
HN