I'm the 3rd option after yes and no. Now, i'm undecided. I Like to wait all the rules, and my personal wall is the "no random advantage". So, at least:
-Same starting roster for everyone OR Everyone can create his roster with limitation
-No injuries (do you want competition? ok, so random "injuries" have different weight, remove it from the match equals everybody can play at 100% of his strenght every match)