he is pretty good...a real scoring machine.
even though his 3pt shooting is amazing,the fact that he has an average of over 60% shooting for his 2 pointers makes him a really tough one to defend.
but since you are the underdog in the game,i would say go with the 3rd player.yes he has poor skills to stop an outside shot but your opponent does not seem to be a fan of outside offenses.he mostly uses inside or a balanced offense.so it will be better if a player with better inside defense stats is defending him