Ok and the question has to be asked, was he a 5 star player, or did he have 5 star potential? Last year I did the same thing I drafted the highest rated player at small forward and he came out with 6th man potential. The first set of stars only indicate his current level of play. The second set are for his potential and they even give a "letter grade" for potential as well.
It just happens. Last years draft sucked for me. This years draft has given me some really solid players I can either train or turn a quick buck with... You win some, you lose some...