Hey, nice thread. Very surprised that both play an outside SF.
I would make and SF like this with 100 points;
SF: JS 10, JR 8, OD 17, HA 7, DR 10, PA 9, IS 10, ID 17, RE 10, SB 2 (neutral)
SF: JS 15, JR 9, OD 17, HA 8, DR 9, PA 9, IS 5, ID 17, RE 9, SB 2 (outside)
SF: JS 9, JR 4, OD 17, HA 5, DR 10, PA 7, IS 14, ID 17, RE 12, SB 5 (inside)