BuzzerBeater Forums

Help - English > Box-and-one engine mechanics

Box-and-one engine mechanics

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
322487.21 in reply to 322487.6
Date: 1/12/2024 10:06:26 AM
Franca Shoemakers Revival
IV.19
Overall Posts Rated:
564564
I have 3 players on my roster whose combination of OD+ID+SB equals 37, being those 3 my best defenders as a consequence.

One of them has very high OD, so I guess that if I choose outside box-and-one he will be the "one".

But what about the other two who are more inside oriented defensively? Is it correct to assume that in the case of inside box-and-one the player who has the higher ID will be chosen ? Or do sublevels play a part on this calculation?

For example:

Player 1: OD 10 ID17 SB 10 = 37
Player 2: OD 9 ID 15 SB 13 = 37

Player 1 has higher ID and should be the "one", right? But if you count sublevels, hipotetically player 1 adds to 37,4 and player 2 adds to 37,6. In this case, will player 2 be chosen as the "one"?

Last edited by Bernspin at 1/12/2024 10:07:37 AM

This Post:
00
322487.23 in reply to 322487.22
Date: 1/13/2024 7:36:58 AM
Franca Shoemakers Revival
IV.19
Overall Posts Rated:
564564
What is the ID/SB of the 3rd player? I'm not convinced he is out of the running for the Inside Defender spot just yet.

the player with high OD that I had left out of the picture have ID and SB around 6-11, let's buzzerbeaterly say.


what about sublevels? eager to read some of your reflections about this. or they are just not relevant in this matter?

about the pickup game, i'm looking forward for the invite (i'm talking about my main team btw).



Last edited by Bernspin at 1/13/2024 8:49:52 AM

This Post:
11
322487.24 in reply to 322487.21
Date: 1/13/2024 12:58:55 PM
Franca Shoemakers Revival
IV.19
Overall Posts Rated:
564564
I have 3 players on my roster whose combination of OD+ID+SB equals 37, being those 3 my best defenders as a consequence.

One of them has very high OD, so I guess that if I choose outside box-and-one he will be the "one".

But what about the other two who are more inside oriented defensively? Is it correct to assume that in the case of inside box-and-one the player who has the higher ID will be chosen ? Or do sublevels play a part on this calculation?

For example:

Player 1: OD 10 ID17 SB 10 = 37
Player 2: OD 9 ID 15 SB 13 = 37

Player 1 has higher ID and should be the "one", right? But if you count sublevels, hipotetically player 1 adds to 37,4 and player 2 adds to 37,6. In this case, will player 2 be chosen as the "one"?



Oh, well, I played this afternoon my main team against my utopia team and the "Player 1" from above basically guarded all the shots from the utopia's best shooter. When "Player 1" got subbed, all the shots became guarded by "Player 2", and when "player 1" went back to court he took the role again of defending every shot of the utopia's best shooter.

In this case utopia played inside iso and main team played inside box-and-one, I don't know if the tactics were different the defensive behaviour would be the same, but I got many answers from this match. Probably lots of people here already knew all of that, but still.

This Post:
11
322487.26 in reply to 322487.17
Date: 1/16/2024 10:31:08 AM
QQguest
I.1
Overall Posts Rated:
334334
I tried two pickup games.
In one game, I used the "inside box and one" tactic, and the best defensive player (best OD, best ID, best SB) in the lineup were set to defend as PG.
In the other game, I used the "outside box and one" tactic, and the best defensive player (best OD, best ID, best SB) in the lineup were set to defend as C.
For the inside box and one game, I cannot be completely sure, but for the outside box and one game, it seems like the best defensive player is probably the "+1" player.
Therefore, it is highly likely that my interpretation of those two games before is wrong.
My previous assumptions naturally do not hold.

This Post:
00
322487.27 in reply to 322487.26
Date: 1/17/2024 5:45:43 AM
Franca Shoemakers Revival
IV.19
Overall Posts Rated:
564564
I tried two pickup games.
In one game, I used the "inside box and one" tactic, and the best defensive player (best OD, best ID, best SB) in the lineup were set to defend as PG.
In the other game, I used the "outside box and one" tactic, and the best defensive player (best OD, best ID, best SB) in the lineup were set to defend as C.
For the inside box and one game, I cannot be completely sure, but for the outside box and one game, it seems like the best defensive player is probably the "+1" player.
Therefore, it is highly likely that my interpretation of those two games before is wrong.
My previous assumptions naturally do not hold.


I'm not sure if that's what you are trying to say, but from what I understand, regardless of the defensive positions the players are set up for the game, the best defensive player (according to the engine) will always defend the opponent's best attacking player, regardless of the set up position of the best defensive player and regardless of the position of the best attacking player. This will almost always disrupt the defensive matchups of the other 4 players, since they will play zone defense. However, I think box-and-one can be effective if well planned, specially against patient and isolation offenses. Actually, if well planned, it can be a kriptonite against patient. Just saying.


Advertisement