BuzzerBeater Forums

BB Global (English) > Difference game engine for playoff games?

Difference game engine for playoff games?

Set priority
Show messages by
From: Tripaw

This Post:
00
12669.22 in reply to 12669.12
Date: 1/17/2008 10:33:50 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
00

For example this game: (2101686). Is't "fair"? Or maybe will be fair tomorrow?[

Izolator Boguchwala has 33 PF and HARDRIVER scores on 27-54 on FT. Fair enough!



Pfff... Better team has more PF and this is only the reason of loosing game? LOL!
This is explination of engine - somehow points of worst team has to be showed...

This Post:
00
12669.23 in reply to 12669.15
Date: 1/17/2008 10:37:38 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
Please... Matchratings showing, how the engine see the differences between teams. For me, if yoa are better in everything and you lose, means that something is far away from ok.


I think this is where the problem is. The best team won't always win, that's never the case anywhere. That's just how it goes.
How could Greece win the Europian Championships soccer a few years ago? They weren't the best team at all.
How could the Pistons(record before the match 28-9) lose to the Knicks (record 9-29).

Having the best team, with the best ratings, does not guarantee a win.



Greece was better, other teams played nothing...
Knicks could beat Pistons, in one game, cause this game dosen't change anything. I don't belive that N.Y. K. could win in Playoff this sezon. Whit anybody...

This Post:
00
12669.24 in reply to 12669.17
Date: 1/17/2008 10:39:37 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
00
Please... Matchratings showing, how the engine see the differences between teams. For me, if yoa are better in everything and you lose, means that something is far away from ok. Or maybe indepedence atack/defense, and other things like rebunding, player skills, etc. dosen't matter in this game? Anyway, engine sucks.


The best team is simply not going to win 100% of the time, no matter how much you want them to.

The engine isn't perfect (none are), but it's one of the best there is.



Of course, I undersand this and I agree... But that means that no matter what you do, you can always loose. Nice...
And for me that means, that playoff whit one game is .... :/

From: Riko

This Post:
00
12669.25 in reply to 12669.21
Date: 1/17/2008 11:45:23 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
1414
Ok. I can agree with you. But this is not fair. You are plaing all sezon, you are training yor players, you are buing new and after all you will be the looser with somebody, who has worst team for two weeks, cause in engine is lot of space for fortune and misfortune... I can agree: better sometimes losse. OK. But not in playoff. And here, we got only one game - that means, that all your work and time in this game is worth piece of... nothinhg. It shouldn't be diffrent?
If engine is like this - let's make real playoff, when one lucku or unlucky game dosen't kick you out...

i agree with you 100% on this. two of my friend trained , buy , sell players all season. spend so much time on this game and than to be kick off in just one game against someone who is playing for 2-3 weeks. Make playoff like it is in RL and random factor will be brought to minimum (still there but much more realistic ).

Or, let's make engine: you are better, you are winner.
If not, it's not a manager game...

this is not a solution. random is one of things that make this kind of games so interesting to play but with more games played in playoff, results will be fair (not 100% but thats why I LOVE THIS GAME ;))

From: dhoff

This Post:
00
12669.27 in reply to 12669.20
Date: 1/17/2008 3:45:04 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
1919
if it wasn't, how could the engine decide what happens in each possession, just by the player ratings..?

I would hope so. The BBs have said as much.

This Post:
00
12669.28 in reply to 12669.23
Date: 1/18/2008 1:27:56 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
506506
Greece was better, other teams played nothing...
Knicks could beat Pistons, in one game, cause this game dosen't change anything. I don't belive that N.Y. K. could win in Playoff this sezon. Whit anybody...


If you only red the examples you totally missed the point.