BuzzerBeater Forums

Suggestions > Farm teams

Farm teams

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
84738.23 in reply to 84738.22
Date: 4/9/2009 11:22:37 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
3737
A. You're not going to waste many seasons to rise to D.I or D.II only to dump your team for one player


That's pretty much irrelevant, IMO. Almost no-one plans to be a farm team. I expect the vast majority of farm teams are regular, successful users who get tired of the game, and choose to liquidate their team and farm instead of just timing out.

That's exactly the situation I'm in in Hattrick, for instance (except I declined to act as a farm team). I didn't intentionally spend real-life years accumulating value to farm, but it just happens that playing successfully then losing interest positioned me perfectly to do so.

This Post:
00
84738.24 in reply to 84738.22
Date: 4/9/2009 11:58:56 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
9191
I think the problem people have with farm teams has nothing to do with a managers choice to be a poor team. It is assumed in many cases that these farm teams arent run by an independant manager who just cares about the NT and doesnt mind losing. I think it is safe to say that at least in some cases these teams are run in addition to a managers real team that they compete with. There should not be a rule prohibiting poor management, as you say. There allready is a rule against one person having multiple accounts, and it seems the concern over farm teams has more to do with this rule than anything else.

This Post:
00
84738.25 in reply to 84738.22
Date: 4/9/2009 12:17:22 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
if B was one point from the BB, i am a bit disappointed ;)

In the beginning they like to see the top players in the top teams, with high but payable salary - when i make a sggestion about salarys last season because i was afraid of a sitution like B it still sound like they expect that it will be possible because we don't know the limits(i didn't believe it)

Now it see like wasting the money of quiting team and aquire those, is the system to play a succesful role in NT also here - and they plan with that.

This Post:
00
84738.26 in reply to 84738.21
Date: 4/10/2009 2:30:49 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
196196
I don't see whats wrong. The team the original poster is referring to is at the bottom of a French 5th division with a 0-12 record. How would replacing it with a bot change anything? The only way this situation could be deemed unfair is if the player was letting some people get a walk over against him and for other teams putting up a fight. That would be unfair. But he's not, he's lost every game this year. The team you're talking about is in an all-bot division too.

I'm all for competition and I hated it when I was in an all-bot league. It was no fun. But the team you're talking about is in a 5th division where a walk-over team is no different from a bot team, except you're guarenteed a win and guarenteed to make your fans happy.

The only downside is he'll get the number one pick in the draft but human teams will get promoted, I know what I'd prefer.

In the end - who's to say how people should play this game? As long as people are playing within the rules it's up to them to play the game in a way they enjoy. If this means logging on once a week and helping develop NT players then what's stopping them? Apart from the draft thing I really can't see how these teams do anything but benefit other human teams.


If you are honestly trying to imply that this is someone genuinely playing the game like this then I would beg to differ.

Let me offer a different explanation. This team is managed by someone that has a main team somewhere else in BB. They log on to just do the bare essentials and develop the player for the good of their country.

Please dont try to convince everyone these teams are run by genuine managers.

This Post:
00
84738.27 in reply to 84738.26
Date: 4/10/2009 2:39:02 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959

Let me offer a different explanation. This team is managed by someone that has a main team somewhere else in BB. They log on to just do the bare essentials and develop the player for the good of their country.


in this case, the team will be banned, as soon as they find it. This is forbidden today.

Please dont try to convince everyone these teams are run by genuine managers.


i got many feedback when i was nt, that it make fun to train the nt players, and that they like to do it again when i was NT coach. And i was sometimes pretty demanding ;)
The NT trainer from my player Avia Schwartz also has the possibility to give me advised for the training, and i sacrifice training from player who could need it most to train him - even if i am not the perfect NT trainer because i switched to two position training for example and can not make that much inside training like he want.

But i can not believe, that someone, just make an additional account for some season to get the necessary money to buy an NT player(and they aren't cheap), to make this second acc to an farm.

This Post:
00
84738.28 in reply to 84738.27
Date: 4/10/2009 3:05:18 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
2525

But i can not believe, that someone, just make an additional account for some season to get the necessary money to buy an NT player(and they aren't cheap), to make this second acc to an farm.


It happens.
The farm team acts as a home where all economic resources are channeled into sustaining just that 1 player. And that player will continue to receive training to insane levels normally unsustainable to performance-based teams. They aren't playing this team for fun, it is just for the 'good' of the NT to have these monster players.

This Post:
00
84738.29 in reply to 84738.28
Date: 4/10/2009 3:19:51 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
why you believe that this can not make fun?

I like to follow the progress of an an NT player, i know guys on ht who find their fun again after they become a farm etc.

This Post:
00
84738.30 in reply to 84738.29
Date: 4/10/2009 3:31:28 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
2525
I think the initial poster did not mean it to be a question of fun, but the long term effects of farms on the distribution of NT players among top teams in BB. Anyhow, I had best leave it to the initial poster to follow up his pointers.

This Post:
00
84738.31 in reply to 84738.30
Date: 4/10/2009 3:45:08 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
but you can not punish someone to play inside the rules, and to forbid training orientated to one position is silly ;)

The way to solve it, was limiting the salaries in one way, who make it possible to play still with them - maybe with an hard cap around 150-225k$ which allows first division teams to play with such players and keep to be succesfull but don't make it easy.

But to start to arguing, this team must be a farm or this is silly in my eyes.

This Post:
00
84738.32 in reply to 84738.31
Date: 4/10/2009 4:20:50 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
2525
Yes, it is still within the rules to do so.

But this thread has been going more along the lines on whether 'farm teams' are a problem in the first place instead of suggestions to address it.

This Post:
00
84738.33 in reply to 84738.32
Date: 4/10/2009 4:27:41 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
959959
the suggestion was made that as cheating and ban then ;)

And i f you can not make an restart around your statra player anymore i think this game suck, or when you have to use salary tables, to see what star player you are allowed to have

Advertisement