Definitely did not out-shoot. But out scored, rebounded, and fouled less.
The assists I take with a grain of salt considering the 2 20+k players and the 7+k player your pg was passing to vs the 4k pf 2 sub 3k guys, the 800 dollar guy and my aged 20+k guy.
The ratings of your team as a team vs mine showed the differences in that.
I guess it depends on definitions of playing better. But I would agree that he did not outperform the guy he was guarding. I also would not say your pg greatly outperformed him either.