Draft question - what order would you put these two players in on a draft list?


[potential is a 4, FT & stamina are not actually known.]
The reason I'm asking is because if you don't know the TSP/specific skills and only have data from scouting & interviewing, the two look like this:
Player 29 is a 4 star, 4 potential, B+ grade SF
Player 10 is a 5 star, 4 potential, A grade SF
My guess is that it is the difference in defensive skills which boosts Player 10's star & grade rating while lowering Player 29's. Which is also supported by another 47 TSP player I found who was only 3 star/C+ due to pitiful in both OD and ID. But Player 29 has a total of 6 more TSP and no atrocious skills, so I'd place him about a half season ahead of Player 10 in terms of training.
I'm mostly trying to figure out how the star/grade ratings relate to actual skills, and this is an example where they just didn't seem to match up well to me and I was wondering what others thought.