I think there should be a separate vote for every player or manager.
Someone decides a few people who they think might be worthy of making the Hall of Fame, and then there is a different vote for each candidate. To make it in all you need is over 50% of the vote (and maybe at least 5 votes or something just to make sure no one gets in only because there were very few votes). After all, if more than half of the people think you should be in the Hall of Fame, shouldn't you be in the Hall of Fame? (and vice versa?)
Last edited by ______ (NZ National Team) at 6/11/2014 3:58:24 PM