It seems as though the consensus is that I want to compete with, or have beginners compete with, D1 or up managers. I don't. They are not in my league/division. One of the threads was talking about BB losing players. A main reason someone quits is because they aren't enjoying themselves. I happen to be hardcore and am willing to stick it out. There is not enough hardcore demographic to keep the game growing. You want to promote a good time. I am trying to offer insight in to the thought process of a new player. When someone is looking to sign up for a basketball manager game the vast majority are thinking about the NBA and want it to be like the NBA.
They want to;
Trade players, draft players, manage a roster, manage contracts (possibly with a salary cap), win games, see progress. No one expects these things to happen right away and all of these things can be done over time (i.e. like a clash of clans where the higher your level, the longer it takes to improve) but when you're a new player on this game and you can't;
Trade/afford players (no one wants a 6th man, they want an MVP), win games, see progress (because training can take too many weeks which is why one of the Frequently Asked Question is 'Why didn't my players bump?'), you aren't getting what you want or were looking for.
I want to say that I do like BB and some of the aspects like the arena and the economy and staff. The one thing I would say is that the current system, which is run by auction, is whoever has the most cash wins. No one can outbid Bill Gates. If you have the most money you can buy the best staff, you can buy the best players whether they are old or trainees, you can have the best arena allowing you to have access to even more money. This is why I suggested giving new players a little extra cash. This also makes the game a little more forgiving if you make a mistake as a new manager.
Maybe BB should have a beginners league where everyone in it is less than 3 seasons old. I have a manager who has been around since season 13 and another since season 17 in my division. No new manager can compete with that level of knowledge or roster talent. If new players are going to get thrown in to the fire, they need an edge or perk so that they aren't destroyed every time they log on.
Things like slowly work up and learn some of the more challenging aspects of the game (i.e. economy, recognizing good and bad talent, training) are never going to be attained if managers don't stick around.
There is a saying we all know 'you learn from your mistakes'. You have to allow people to make mistakes and not get killed for them. Players will just leave. Let them learn and promote them to stay.
None of this is up for debate. Nothing I've said isn't fact as those were the things I was looking for, questions I asked, aspects I wanted or situations I found myself in.
I posted a suggestion from one perspective, which got responses from what appears to be some of the more seasoned players. I believe that one day I'll be in your shoes and possibly think the way you do, but for now try to think outside of your current standing and look at some suggestions from another perspective.
LTJ
Last edited by LTJ at 7/25/2014 2:00:41 AM