Honestly I don't have much time before I leave for my vacation, but perhaps
(32846740) is decent. Ismael and Eric Grubbs are both excellent scorers (47% and 51% FG%) but I only had one real good ID guy at the time. So I went Inside Box and 1, and held Ismael to 7-21 shooting and Eric to 6-19 shooting. Not suffocating, but decent, and enough to pull out the 3 point win. If I had done Man to Man, whoever my good ID guy wasn't defending probably would've had a field day. Just my theory.
Also, maybe
(32846729). Manhattan had been playing Pilas, a big, at SF and I wanted to Run and Gun with 3 guards so I did a Box and One (outside, this was before I got my good ID guy) to help. The 54% shooter for the season went 4-19 and I won by 4. If that was Man to Man, I imagine he would've tore up my guard that I had at SF. Again, just my guess.
I'd have to dig deeper into the play by play to see if there are any extra clues.