I went 2-6 against the other division but feel like 2 of those games could have swung either way.
That might be a pretty decent way to gauge things.
Vs. Great 8:ChiTown 6-2
Machines 6-2
SlipNslidE 4-4
Jests 2-6
Postal 2-6
Bass 2-6
PSP 1-7
Vipers 0-8 (but botified, so kinda irrelevant)
Vs. Big 8:Hobos 7-1
Quakers 6-2
PBS 6-2
Koalas 6-2
RiverDogs 6-2
REO 4-4
Shock 5-3
sphinx 1-7
This is rather inconclusive, however, when you take into consideration that a fair number of us were still in the Cup during most of this time, and there were league matches thrown to make up for rough Cup draws. Also, everyone in the Great 8 got a free win against Vipers, who accounted for the only win by sphinx (who also has gone 2 weeks without logging in, and basically has given away 3-5 free wins to the Big 8 during that span).
In addition, there's home/away to factor into things, and I really can't be bothered to go through all the games and tally up who played where and whether they won or lost. I'm guessing it's an even 4-4 split between home and away, but as I said I haven't checked, and sometimes the schedule is screwey with that type of stuff.
More Big 8 teams lasted further in the Cup than Great 8 teams. Was that based on strength of schedule, depth of team, or just random dumb luck?