BuzzerBeater Forums

Although I never supported daytrading, it should not be eliminated from the game. It's good how it is now I guess.

Daytraders keep the market alive, without them there will be a lot less transfers, which makes it harder to find the player you want. Prices will go up, since there are less players on the market.

It's just another tactic how to play the game.

Who are you? Where is Mr. Patjebono? The real one I mean!

I agree we shoudn't eliminate completely the DT but I also agree with the proposal to make a stronger taxationif you wanna sell a player bought in the first month, 50% first week, 60% second week, 70% third week, 80% four week. It's easy to make skill trading but in case of ST at least you must train a player (leaving training to another one), in DT you've only to put a price and take the profit.

A little OT; I think as written some weeks ago that there are a lot of money available now, probably too much...

I understand that the transfer market is a very attractive with a daytraders... but play the game against them - it is just impossible, because of their's advantage. That is the main reason to fix that problem. If you want a glory, you have to understand a whole game - not just a transfer market.

The market will be barely dead without them - but you could see if you will train a player and put him there - you will FINALLY see his real price. Our transfer market is an auction and if there is any player if fact interesting - is normal that there will be the interest from the many club's owners...

..if you give them by this forced way a more "goods" to buy, the price will fall down, but in fact - the money will be earned by a daytraders and NOT by the club, which growed them and do not daytrade.

In other words - if you need a player, you have to train him or buy for his real price and everyone will be in the same situation like you...

There is a lot of "for" and "against" arguments according to DT - but if should be this game so real, unique and interesting that it seems now - we should to focus on support of a managers, which play this game like should be played and don't give the advantage to a legal cheaters which have just a plenty of a time and do nothing for a basketball

that's my opinion

I just think BB is too young to limit the daytrading even more. There aren't that much active teams yet, so the amount of players and the players listed on the TL is fairly low.

At some point when BB grows even more to lets say an average of 10.000 users online, then there will always be enough players listed and you will mostly see bidwars because there are more users who want to buy players. Then daytraders aren't needed anymore (imo), because there is a higher demand and a higher offer. The TL will be way more active then.

Now when traders will disappear there will be less players on the market, and since the community is relatively small this will hurt BB imo.


@ Ned. I realised how hard it is to buy decent players. When I look around on the TL and I want a PG with strong OD, PA and HD I only got 2 matches. What will happen if there will be even less players. If we completely stop traders now the market will be dead, since BB is just too small atm. Don't get me wrong, I'm still con-daytrading, but we need them now I think ;).

Ned. I realised how hard it is to buy decent players

Sorry Patje, but it's hard ot buy decent players simply because there are a lot of people richer than you. The DTs don't create new players, they are speculating on the market. If I put a player for sale for 400k, there is a player that buys him and resell the same player at 600k. Without DTs probably the player will be not sell for 400k but I can put him again on the market at 350k. I've made some DT transfers, I never trained a player, bought and sold, I didn't create anything, only a profit for myself. Now with this money I can offer more $ then you on a "decent" player on the market, are you happy about this situation? ;) Of course this is just an example but if you see a good player and you've cash 1 million and a DT has 2 millions, I think that probably this player will be bought by the DT...

just think twice before putting player on TL with low price for hope that more users will fight for him... Nothing else you need... cause if day-trader gets player for 100k who`s worth is 600k it`s your own fault... If you`re taking the risk by putting you player for much more lower price then he`s worth so be responsible for that....

That`s just my opinion...

Sorry Patje, but it's hard ot buy decent players simply because there are a lot of people richer than you.

Yeah that's true, but this will happen even more if the market was smaller.

If the players aren't on the market nobody can buy them ;). With less players on the market prices will go up even more, since the players are more rare then. So when all daytraders are gone we have less players on the market, if I want to buy one then I need 1,4 million instead of 1 million for example.

Now the daytraders have way more money yes, and they can buy any player they want, but I can buy all those other players because the average price is lower than when they wouldn't be here.

You have a right about volume of users - this limitation should be done on Hattrick a years ago and it still is in there - and users got used to it. I talked about this theme on our national conference in Hattrick few times with the users and they are using Daytrading or Skilltrading so long that they have now so distorted perception that they mostly doesn't see that it should be a football and not some kind of business game "keep the market alive and win the Hattrick Masters title".

I would to risk that on the market will be so small amount of players - because the big competitions would win ONLY honest teams, with a managers behind - which in fact know something and got theirs glory thanks to theirs knowledge and wisdom.

The training of a players is a slow to put any quality candidate for sale in a short time and is logical that the market will be without players which travel from the team to the other - dead, but -

There should be the other way how to supply our managers by a players without ruining of a honest game. We can get a 1 pickup from draft in advance or by offering of a free players at the begining of a every season - you know there are a lot of fired players which trained by theirs own, got better and want to get back to play as a professional.

The possibilities are unlimited, there has to be just a open mind which will understand that by a daytrading will be the old mistakes from a old games repeated again!

Think about it, it IS a mistake to accept the easiest and most wrong solution

Ned. I realised how hard it is to buy decent players

Sorry Patje, but it's hard ot buy decent players simply because there are a lot of people richer than you.

yes, and Patjes replay is what I agree too, and to add:
I think that teams in your environment (read same lenght of playtime, and same division) are in the same situation, so it does not nessecarily give you a disadvantage compared to your direct concurents... I think it only normal for Div I teams to be able to buy better players than lower division teams.

I also copied this sentence from amongst the posts:
My point is that the day traders are setting the minimum bidding point for everyone else.
I don't agree here. If they ask too much, people will not buy anymore, and wait until the same player comes along for less. Daytraders, if if you combine them aal, can NOT buy every last player on the TL, especially not if they can't sell the ones the already bought, so eventually players will be able to buy for less than what daytraders ask if they ask too much. One could also buy a little less good and train him up as well, so day traders will also need to buy every available players that is almost as good, this is not realistic. What daytraders can do is see what the price is that people want to pay for a type of player, then look for them on the TL and see if they can get one for less, and relist him. It's a lot of work, and imho they deserve the money they make that way. I occasionally search the TL, and even want to buy 1 or 2 young players for my own to train them, and if you look at my history, you will see I haven't bought in a long time. I've been bidding on tons of players, and did not get 1 of them, simply because I don't want to pay the amounts they went for...
It is not unlimited, and it sure is not the daytraders who set the price, not at all !!! the only thing daytraders do, is play with the TL, some gamble, some wait until they see an almost sure investment, but none, can set (lower, nor raise) the prices for players.

So in your case the best solution would be player contracts... Like in Fifa Manager (yes I know that one is football), there is no chance to day-trade in it... Just because of limits how many time player can change team per season, as well Player character (if he don`t wanna leave your club, the only way is to fire him and pay all his salary at once....)


but all this would need really huge amount of memory (and work in programming as well), which our servers don`t have...

But Sir Lord of Doom, the question is: who's taking advantage from DT? Do u really think that the users are taking an advantage? I think that DT is an advantage only for who's making it and in this case I don't see any reason to keep alive this sistem to play. I can understand that some people considers trading funny that's why I don't want it will be cancelled but pls I think nobody can say that without DTs the market should be dead. What is the real problem is that training players is worst than trading players, you can obtain better and faster results if you trade players instead of train them and imo that's not good at all. Anyway my position I think should be clear, with 5 millions in my pocket it should be easy to win a championship; what hurts me is that if there are 100 people with 5 millions cash, you'll find those 100 guys in the first 100 positions...