BuzzerBeater Forums

Okay I have a couple of things to point out (some may have been pointed out by previous posters).

1. Height is irrelevant. So the fact that they are 6 feet or 7 feet doesn't affect rebounds at all in the game.
2. If you watch a basketball game, you will notice that missed shots are often rebounded close to the ring. This is common sense. As Centers and Powerforwards play closer to the ring they get more rebounds in general irrespective of the rebounding skill.
3. The opponent and tactics come in to play a lot which could explain why the rebounding averages per game were so close.

I understand your arguments, but it seems that the rebounding skill is wasted on guards. What level rebounding would a guy like Jason Kidd have in this game?

It seems to me that there is a slight discrepancy when a guard pulls down 19 rebounds just because you play him at center. 10-12 would be high enough. Not enough effort is being made by wingmen to get to rebounds.

It could be a freak game, but yeah it's odd that an atrocious rebounder should grab 19 boards in one game. Speaking as someone who, back in the day when I actually played a lot of ball, was probably close to an "atrocious" rebounder (my eyesight isn't so good, my jump shot was solid since I didn't need to see the target when I shot, and rebounding requires good eyesight to go with the instincts), I know that even the worst of rebounders can get a ball to that bounces (and often rolls) away, sort of like the mutt getting the occasional crumb that falls away from the big dogs. Put me in the middle of the scrum, maybe I'll grab a live ball off the rim if it bounces away from the better rebounder and nobody else is attacking the rim, so that's how the rebounding stats go up for the atrocious rebounder playing more in the post, more opportunities for odd rebounds. But I know what it was like down there, the best I could usually do if I was in the post was to try to push my guy away from the rim so one of my teammates could get the rebound, or at least push my guy away and how the ball hits the floor where I stand a chance at collecting it. Granted, being the smallest guy on the court was as much a factor in my atrocious rebounding skills as the eye sight thing, but that just meant it took me longer to get the knack for rebounding. (Oddly enough, I'm a little bigger now but slower and with worse eye sight, and yet I'm a much better rebounder now than I ever was, which I attribute to experience and having a better sense of how the ball will come off the rim, even if I can't see the shot so well.) Anyway, the point is, either 19 rebounds was a freak game, or the other team had some serious rebounding issues that an atrocious rebounder could take advantage of. I'd like to see a link to that game, otherwise it's just all speculation.

The fact is that the guards of both team will not have more than a little percentages of all the rebounds,so your guard can win the battle against his adversary,but the total number of rebound will be however relatively low,aslo if your guard is a great rebounder
When I trained a Sf some season ago,when I put him in PG position because of training he grabs 5-6 rebounds,when i put him at Pf or C he grabbed over double digit rebounds

I had said the guy had average rebounding, not atrocious. But I re-checked and he only has mediocre rebounding. Had an average of 4.4 rebounds per game - obviously the no. got a huge kick because of the 19 in 1 game.

Thats what I was saying is the problem. That too many rebounds go to the battle between the centers and not enough to the guards.

You have to account for who the opponent plays and i don't see anything strange in that game considering that your mediocre rebounder went up against 3k salary shooting guard playing the pf position.

Rebound skill is overvalued