hmm that is an interesting comparison. I personally would say they would be very similar and that it depends what you need for your team.
Personally, I think that the first player is better for a couple of reasons.
Firstly the 58k salary has far better primary skills which is very important for a PF.
Secondly, even though the 41k player has great secondary skills, the first player has okay secondary skills and the difference in secondary skills isn't enough to make up the difference in primary skills.
Also stamina for the first player is far better.
Basically, in my opinion, I would rather have 3 extra rebounding points and 2 extra inside shot points instead of 7 extra jump shot points and a dozen other secondary points.
But I think performance would be similar, so depends completely on what tactics you use, and what your opponents are like.
Note that the first player has better outside defence than the second as well.