Well he scored 26 points in the first quarter and your team scored 21, so this mean he was up by 5 after 12 minutes. With 36 minutes left to play you still had a chance. Then in the second quarter he extended his lead to 13 by scoring 29 points to your 21. This put the overall halftime score at 55-42. In the 3rd quarter his team again held you to 21 points or less only giving up 18 points and scoring 23 to extend the lead even more to a 18 point lead. At this point your chances looked slim and he then outscored you by 5 in the 4th quarter. How he won in the end is kind of a mystery to me but I think it is probably the fact that you got outscored in every quarter or it could be the fact that he put the ball in the basket more times.
I think the best explanation is that your team being from New york bored a bus to get to the game which turned out to be his "Noob Schoolbus" where he then took you to school. At school your team then learned that his team was unstoppable and your team went in there scared and didn't play very well especially since you were playing in a parking lot (His arena name)and were afraid of all the cars parked in the middle of the court.