What im saying is i wouldnt take any of those players. I would try to get as much OD as i could and then higher IS but lower ID.
Besides IS, how about the effect of Jump Shot? I like centres who are good at JS, so that I could switch playing him in both PF and C positions.
Say JS / IS / ID: 10 / 14 / 12 vs 8 / 16 / 14 , which one prefer?
I could understand the importance of OD, so that he could defense the opponent's SF more effectively. But 10 OD would be very rare for big men, right? For me (I am in Div III), I think 7 or 8 OD would be good enough.