I would get rid of player 1, I don't really see him being good at anything. He could become a defensive C, but he is a little short to train in that respect. Player 2 looks great. I would look around for a couple more trainees. Doesn't need to be anything amazing, 18-19 year old stars/allstars are ok if you can get them for less than $10k.
I would start with some 1v1 FW to get his driving+handling up to 17-18 or so (I'm talking 8-9 in each of handling and driving). Then thinking about a little bit of OD (up to about 9 or 10, will be slow based on height). Add a bit of passing, shoot for 8 or 9 (10-12 if you are feeling ambitious). Then just hammer inside skills and JS until they cap. That should give you a pretty good PF for D III and excellent for D IV.
edit: if you are dead set on player 1, I would still follow the guide above and just have him along for the ride. I wouldn't expect great things, but he could be an ok PF for a D IV or D V team.
Last edited by tictacshack at 5/3/2014 12:10:48 PM