BuzzerBeater Forums

Woooooow, you almost completed the biggest upset of the season !

Nicely taken advantage of De Klerk's injury ... Maybe a patient with your best outside shooter on SG would have worked, but that was a great attempt !

Once again, it highlights how much injuries are unbalancing the game.

Oops, right, I always forget about that ! :/

Well, indeed so close!

Hopefully, I didn't watch the game... I hope my player will come back soon as it will be difficult to be champion without him.

Nicely taken advantage of De Klerk's injury ... Maybe a patient with your best outside shooter on SG would have worked, but that was a great attempt !

That doesn't work against a zone!

I think i made good tactical choices. The game really could have gone both sides. I just had some bad luck in the end with too much missed shots.
It would have been the greatest win and biggest surprise of the season especially since i played at mplume's arena.
But i am not disappointed at all. My team played an amazing game and almost eliminated the big favorite for the title who hasnt lost any game so far this season. So i am very satisfied of my team's performance in this playoff game.



Last edited by Eagle at 10/10/2018 6:44:53 AM

Yep, my bad, patient doesn't work on a zone and mplume always plays 3 - 2. Yet that was a great effort.

However, it is an injury that made that possible, otherwise I think mplume would have won it with a margin. I really dislike injuries in this game, although I have been able to dodge them over the last 2 seasons.

However, it is an injury that made that possible, otherwise I think mplume would have won it with a margin. I really dislike injuries in this game, although I have been able to dodge them over the last 2 seasons.

I don't agree with you on this one. Injuries are a part of the game, and just as in real life, teams can be heavily impacted by injuries of good players. I've had my part of injuries as well, but since this game must simulate the real life situation as much as possible, they are an indispensable difficulty one must live with. I find it very normal that there are injuries, it is a simulation basket game after all, and not an arcade game, where you can switch on or off the injuries in the game options, lol.


Last edited by Eagle at 10/10/2018 4:12:19 PM

In real life, players are requesting transfers if they're aiming for a better team. There are contract talks, whereas both team and player are trying to get the better of a deal. Yet somewhere the game has to draw a line between what will be picked from "real life" and what won't.

Managing his team to be successful while at the same time turning a profit is a difficulty. Training a youngster and turn him into a star is a difficulty. Optimizing weekly playing times is a difficulty. You can circumvent those by playing cleverly, carefully, or planning ahead.

If injuries were the result of, let's say, accumulated gaming time over the season (or numbers of weeks exceeding a total number of minutes played, and so on), then managing them would be a difficulty, and you could plan accordingly. I'm not saying this would be realistic, but yet it would be another thing you'll have to manage (which is convenient in a management game).

In the current state of things, injuries are just random. Sometimes they mess with your strategy, sometimes they don't. No amount of planning or clever play will deter them (with the exception of the doctor, but I can recall a team with a level 6 doctor picking a 4-weeks injury on a key player anyway, so their influence is limited).

Random strikes with game shape, and sometimes in games as well. A random factor like injuries, and one that is critical to one's season is something I don't like.

But of course, if you tell me that a random factor is better than careful calculations, maybe you're the one into arcade game, "lol".

Managing his team to be successful while at the same time turning a profit is a difficulty. Training a youngster and turn him into a star is a difficulty. Optimizing weekly playing times is a difficulty. You can circumvent those by playing cleverly, carefully, or planning ahead.

If injuries were the result of, let's say, accumulated gaming time over the season (or numbers of weeks exceeding a total number of minutes played, and so on), then managing them would be a difficulty, and you could plan accordingly. I'm not saying this would be realistic, but yet it would be another thing you'll have to manage (which is convenient in a management game).

In the current state of things, injuries are just random. Sometimes they mess with your strategy, sometimes they don't. No amount of planning or clever play will deter them (with the exception of the doctor, but I can recall a team with a level 6 doctor picking a 4-weeks injury on a key player anyway, so their influence is limited).

Ofcourse injuries are just random. Just like in real life, you never know if and/or when you will have injuries. If you could foresee your injuries in a paranormal way with a glass ball or something, then what would be realistic in that?!

But of course, if you tell me that a random factor is better than careful calculations, maybe you're the one into arcade game, "lol".

Don't turn my words around please, i never said random factor is better than careful calculations. It's not a question of favoring one over the other. Both types are important in a simulation game.

But we are talking injuries here, and just as it happens to be, injuries just are a random factor, like in real life. There are many other difficulties which do require careful calcultations, unlike injuries.

Last edited by Eagle at 10/10/2018 6:50:56 PM

Ofcourse injuries are just random. Just like in real life, you never know if and/or when you will have injuries. If you could foresee your injuries in a paranormal way with a glass ball or something, then what would be realistic in that?!

Fair point, but I was merely trying to point out that another injury system might exist, with something more than just "shit happens". Of course that's my opinion, and I certainly don't expect everyone to share it (what would be the point of having an opinion otherwise).

Don't turn my words around please, i never said random factor is better than careful calculations. It's not a question of favoring one over the other. Both types are important in a simulation game.

I didn't mean to completely remove injuries, but a more controlled and less random event would have pleased me. My view on management games is that it always needs less random and more complexity. This combination has made me quit other sport management games, most notably hattrick. Unfortunately, when I want random now, I log into Hearthstone, this wasn't always like that though :(

But I respect your point of view, I just don't share it. And maybe I wrote it more agressively than I wanted to, sorry for that.

As for injuries, so far I've been relatively spared, but I can imagine how frustrating it must be when a season gets crushed by an untimely injury, whether one is going for a promotion, a trophy or merely fighting for survival in the play-downs. (I really could see myself yelling at my computer, not that it would change anything) This is easily the work of one season, if not more, that can be reduced to ashes because of random, that's a bit harsh.