BuzzerBeater Forums

I will add defense, and team play(!) on Jordan's part, and involving everyone. He was a team-oriented player despite his scoring ability.

And shooting. Jordan was a MUCH better shooter...

Fair enough... if that's the limits of the time machine then (so... we can't bring 'em back/forward when they're younger?), understood.

Sidenote: how do you guys think the Finals impacted this entire conversation?

A young current player (lebron in this example) is sent to past to play vs those players when they were playing (so young too).

The finals only made more visible what was already not a mistery: Lebron James (currently, at least) lacks the mental strenght required to match his talent.

Last edited by Supermán at 6/15/2011 6:19:28 AM

What makes you think Lebron is on steroids and former players like... KArl Malone... were not?? Karl Malone's body doesn't look more "natural".

I watched Jordan, I watched Miller and I watched the Knicks back in those days and I disagree with you. Defense back then was not even close than today's. Objects in rearview mirror may appear closer than they are. Check back the videos & compare open mindedly.

The 80s is not the point of discussion, I'm just trying to show how the game evolved. But it's not in the 80s there was no D-fence nad then in the Jordan era suddenly it appeared and we saw the best defenses ever and then when Jordan retired defenses suddenly dissapeared again as you seem to be saying...

Jordan's team play appeared late in his career, his first 5 or more years he was a go to basket player. Lebron has averaged 7 assists in his career. SO what you mean for a better team play?? Jordan had more leadership, no doubt, and he gave his teammates more confidence, I agree there 100% and he had a more positive attitude out of the field. But again, Cleveland with lebron were first and without were last, that may say something about Lebron.

Lebron has a ton of haters (me included). He earned that with his tatoo "The chosen one", with the show that ended up with him in Miami, with his attitude inside and outside the court, etc... but that's not what we are supossed to discuss here and I think many of you are writing very "hate-influenced"

I have a bud whose wife is a psychologist. She says she thinks LeBron has some anxiety issues.

But I disagree on D, and I think a large part of that's officiating: it was DEFINITELY tougher in the 80s - they could get away with a heap more. Hell, listen to Kevin McHale talk about the difference between now and then (he discussed this very point on NBA Today).

Defense back then was not even close than today's. Objects in rearview mirror may appear closer than they are. Check back the videos & compare open mindedly.

(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mlolzcidq0o) - Bulls Pistons ECF '91, two of the best def in the NBA that year

(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z-QbU-SBJQ8) - Bulls Heat EFC '11, two of the best def this year

Same intensity, frantic rotations on def trying to close down shooters, full court pressure. The main difference? Much better TV resolution!

Last edited by brian at 6/15/2011 9:50:14 AM

I agree 100% with you and the GM who posted after you, you explained better than I why it's impossible to compare this 2 players.

I don´t think it is a coincidence that a lot more scoring from perimeter players came around the same time as the handchecking and 3-second rules.

In 2007 Phil Jackson said Jordan would average 45 points with these rules and Joe Dumars said it would be flat out impossible to defend Jordan the way the game is called now. Joe D should know a thing or two about that.

Though hard to compare by watching highlights, there is evidence in your video of much better defense now than then...

I could write a lot about that but if you really think defense hasn't evolved and it's the same now than back then and you show this videos as proof, then nothing I could post would change your mind.

So just a few tips:

individual defense is ABOUT speed, focus, timing and agility. Team defense adds to this scouting of the opposing team players and tendencies and team offensive playbook. There's no discussion about players being now faster and stronger and I think we can agree now there's much more information, and therefore better scouting.

in your video:

Jordan is scoring a medium range shot from the FT line without double team defense several times.

I can't recall a single play when he was denied the ball by the defense, even though many times there's no pick at all for him.

Defense is too close to basket and that's why all passes to the open guy end up in an easy shot. In most of the cases the ball is in Jordan hands close to the 3p line and all the other 4 defenders are very close to the basket, that's why Jordan is given a lot of space to play one on one and shoot from the ft line with single cover.

Offensive 5 on 5 is really slow and many times there no motion at all and offensive players don't create space neither, you don't see that in the other video were there's much more offensive movement in players without the ball.





Last edited by Supermán at 6/15/2011 5:54:38 PM