you could build those easily with 30k players, too with the different that all skills are weeker^^
Like the example Josef Ka gave? I am not sure how easy it would be to create player B in his example. With 67 pops needed in outside skills for a big man, no one will want to spen 8 mil on him, he will be in his 30s :) (40s?)
Great post, well thought out and articulated argument. I think the major flaw in your idea is that it limits the plans and cushion the well established teams have in place for thier future. Imagine the reaction of teams allready over the cap when they are told to start making cuts? Taxing the rich makes for a short political career, to borrow a phrase.
I think it is a great thing that you place the future of the game over protecting your situation. Kudos