I'm not gonna go over every point. Everybody can read what I wrote and your rebuttal and can form his/her opinion. I don't think A is widespread, B is a concern and C is a real issue, because a NT manager can impose builds on managers (linked to point A) and should have a conversation going with the managers about both training and GS. Point C has happened and people mentioned it openly on the forums so it's not an hypotetical issue.
I'm not judging anybody nor knocking down anybody, but perhaps we shall ask NBBA managers if they'd feel comfortable with someone competing for the title and being the NT at the same time. We could do the same exercise with the ipercompetitive Polish D1 guys what they think now that one won the election (and another came in second).
All I'm saying is that being the NT manager gives you an advantage over the competition. Large or small (are you're now trying to make it look like) it is still an advantage and it is not nonexistant (as you tryed to imply before, if I understood you correctly)
Please do ask the other NBBA managers if they feel comfortable with the NT manager in D1. Go do that. You didn't understand me quite correctly. I'm arguing being the NT manager gives you no competitive edge over other D1 teams. If you abuse it (look at everyone's skills, call up only your guys for scrimmages, etc) then you can gain a small benefit. But using your NT capabilities in that way is quite rare, and certainly has nothing to do with rwystyrk or any other top manager who has been involved with their NT that we're discussing here. You said this:
No, the gold is obviously a great achievement, but for the D1 titles it should be considered that he managed the NT for over 10 seasons and that gave him a significant advantage. Unless someone can confirm he didn't have nor bought any NT prospect/player during his tenure.
I'm arguing that it didn't give him any advantage that was unavailable to him as a regular D1 member. You're arguing that it was a significant advantage that we can only let slide if he didn't have an NT player in 10 seasons.
If there was a "significant advantage," D1 teams would be lining up to be NT manager. They're not - not even close.