I generally think the points per 100 ratings are the best guide, and in those you got thoroughly smashed
That said, that was probably reflected in the game (Baxter shot better), it was just the rebounding and the large amount of FTs that got you over the line. The rebounding looks a bit odd, given you were behind in the rating, but you are right, it might be a matchup thing.
I'd still maintain you were pretty lucky though