BuzzerBeater Forums

Australia - IV.7 > Private league 10

Private league 10

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
212354.594 in reply to 212354.593
Date: 10/3/2012 9:56:24 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
179179
how about instead of nominating positions for PG/SG/SF/PF/C we can do something like
Guards
Forwards
Centre?

I know i play my guys out of position a lot depending on tactics that i am employing

This Post:
00
212354.595 in reply to 212354.594
Date: 10/3/2012 9:59:10 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
289289
Don't see why that wouldn't work.

From: mllama

This Post:
00
212354.596 in reply to 212354.594
Date: 10/3/2012 10:10:54 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
326326
Personally, I'd rather do it per position. Just because doing it that way will mean we end up with no sfs on the team, and I feel they deserve some love :p

This Post:
00
212354.597 in reply to 212354.592
Date: 10/3/2012 10:20:34 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
14651465
A great list Whitebeard, I don't see any problem in putting the whole list to the people and letting the people decide. I think Bainsy's timeline of from end of game this week to start of game next week is also great. 3-2-1 is great, maybe we can use that to create a proper 12 man team. Starter and reserve for each position and two more wildcards, the two best guys that missed out, some positions are really crowded with talent while in others there will be some players getting all the 3 votes.

From: whompa

This Post:
11
212354.598 in reply to 212354.597
Date: 10/3/2012 11:53:33 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
5656
i like the idea of each position as well, but hey i have barely any input so who cares what an Ass like me thinks

From: tremell

This Post:
00
212354.599 in reply to 212354.579
Date: 10/4/2012 12:27:03 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
224224
Dunno whether Jahe has done enough, though the SF crop is pretty thin (he's averaging under 10ppg though).


Cmon now Jahe's PPG is low thanks to incidents when your hacks injured him after 11min (as a square up for my guys taking out Yalduz).....He also had a game of 19min. So 2 low min games out of 5 so far.

I feel like the wombats have beef with the Jahe :-p

Last edited by tremell at 10/4/2012 12:27:33 AM

From: Mr J

This Post:
00
212354.600 in reply to 212354.599
Date: 10/4/2012 8:22:45 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
441441
I agree with all. 1 week timeframe, 3-2-1 voting and voting on all 5 positions. My question is how is the voting done? Secret votes sent to chosen manager? Open voting in a specially created thread? Of course this will allow people to go back and forth changing votes if they please. On the positive side, open voting will really generate discussion?

An alternate way to vote: open up five threads with five polls for the 5 positions. In this way each manager can vote only once in each of the five polls from a collection of player names put forward?

Problems:

1. Hard to maintain 1 week voting timeframe;
2. We lose the 3-2-1 voting opportunity; and
3. Secret vote where we can't be sure only Fishbowl members are voting

Positives:

1. Creates threads where nominated players can be discussed;
2. Creates a visual update of potential Allstars from day-to-day which adds excitement;
3. Allows Fishbowl participants and non-participants a chance to vote

Other?

@Whitebeard, agree with Dogan being seen as PG and Marcelo "Hot Rod" Rodriguez at SG.

From: MrGoodKat

To: Mr J
This Post:
00
212354.601 in reply to 212354.600
Date: 10/4/2012 6:59:39 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
612612
I reckon it be done in secret and sent to whitebeard if he is happy to do it, or yoda and myself. Creating 10 threads is a bit excessive. I also think the discussion would be able to take place in the nominations thread if there were some abouit the players.

What does everyone else think?

Garrie Addison (18085302). The G-Adder striking blows since season 15
This Post:
00
212354.602 in reply to 212354.601
Date: 10/4/2012 7:46:53 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
7878
I would just have everyone write down their choices here. I don't agree with it being a secretive thing. Is it seriously going to hurt someones feeelings if you don't vote for their player? I would like to see who everyone votes for. Bit thatsjust my opinion.

The Platypus Federation: http://www.buzzerbeater.com/community/fedoverview.aspx?fedid=19109
This Post:
00
212354.603 in reply to 212354.601
Date: 10/4/2012 7:49:39 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
14651465
Doesn't need to be any official polls or seperate threads. Just one voting thread and everyone can write their votes.

PG
3 Barton
2 McArthur
1 Willy

etc

KISS!

From: Mr J

This Post:
00
212354.604 in reply to 212354.603
Date: 10/4/2012 9:06:30 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
441441
Doesn't need to be any official polls or seperate threads. Just one voting thread and everyone can write their votes.

PG
3 Barton
2 McArthur
1 Willy

etc

KISS!


Keeping it simple is always good. Only mentioned it because, as you can see, people will have opinions. :-)
\

I'm happy with the transparent 3-2-1 voting in a thread purposely created which can be added to and reused eachs eason.

So, after tonight's game we begin voting?


Advertisement