all true all true.
If I have to choose, I'd pick player 2.
But if I can keep both, I'd use them depending on my opponent.
If he plays pressing, go for the passing guy.
If he plays outside attack, go for the defense guy. Actually, always go for the defense guy, unless your opponent is pressing you. ;) (at least, that's what I'd do...)
They are not your friends; they dispise you. I am the only one you can count on. Trust me.