BuzzerBeater Forums

BB Global (English) > Ethical?

Ethical?

Set priority
Show messages by
This Post:
00
108191.7 in reply to 108191.5
Date: 9/3/2009 9:47:32 AM
Jokehim Maniacs
SBBL
Overall Posts Rated:
188188
Second Team:
Jokehim Maniacs II
I think that simplest way to solve it is to give a message if your player is in national team on daily update. If he was not at last update then tell the manager that he is chosen for national team.

I think that the annoyance to users by letting them know that their player was picked and dropped is unnecessary in my opinion.

I think that current system where you can check skills during season break is the best possible. It would be worse if the national coach could see skills for every user during the whole season and it would certainly be worse if you could not see skills for players in the national team.

Another alternative is to give the national team coach full access to every player in the country during off season but I am certainly not favoring that as that would give the national coach a big advantage for their own team.

The suggestion to instead write a note that player was on test training also makes sense to me even if I favor to completely skip a message about chosen in national team if it is for just minutes ...

This Post:
00
108191.8 in reply to 108191.7
Date: 9/3/2009 10:30:58 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
3838
I favor to completely skip a message about chosen in national team if it is for just minutes ...
That's my nr 1 choice too, but if it has to be one it should be formed in a way that doesn't give false hope for managers.
I think that simplest way to solve it is to give a message if your player is in national team on daily update. If he was not at last update then tell the manager that he is chosen for national team.
I would prefer to PM the manager if a player of his were given a spot on NT. Both out of courtesy and to make sure the player recieves training, but writing it in NT press release is also a good way which could be combined by PM, however both of these would depend on the NT coach activity level (in my opinion you should be into it if you decide to run for NT coach).

This Post:
00
108191.9 in reply to 108191.1
Date: 9/3/2009 10:48:22 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
303303
This is completely ethical and is expected - any NT coach worth his salt will be getting as much information as he can to further the goals of his NT.

NO ONE at this table ordered a rum & Coke
Charles: Penn has some good people
A CT? Really?
Any two will do
Any three for me
Any four will score
Any five are live
This Post:
00
108191.10 in reply to 108191.9
Date: 9/3/2009 11:49:00 AM
Overall Posts Rated:
409409
This is completely ethical and is expected - any NT coach worth his salt will be getting as much information as he can to further the goals of his NT.


Yes it is, but I also think it is not entirely correct to tell the league that X player has been nominated for NT in a situation where he has only been scouted. Something similar just happen en mi league and that manager feel bad when realize that it was only scouted.

Is like the same comment I made when somebody suggest to put in the History or Hall of Fame if your player has been nominated for NT. Virtually every 18 yo player will high potential has been nominated for his U21 NTM, even if he has not been in the team for more than a minute every season.

Maybe a good posibility will be to report this if when the daily/weekly update occurs and the player is still nominated, then it will be put as a highlight.

This Post:
00
108191.11 in reply to 108191.10
Date: 9/3/2009 12:10:23 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
3838
Let's just say I am not looking forward to the new league news feature flooded with "team X celebrates that player X have been nominated to nation X's NT", not just the national players, but every decent player in every team. So much for those weeks news. If I am lucky I might get a glimpse of them ...if I refresh rapidly enough...

From: Plotts
This Post:
00
108191.12 in reply to 108191.11
Date: 9/3/2009 2:19:29 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
1111
See, I think you shouldn't feel slighted if your player only makes it on the team for a half a day. Think of it like a try out. Your player leaves, you're proud of him. He comes back the next day and says he didn't make the cut, and you say better luck next time kid.

What's the big deal?

This Post:
00
108191.13 in reply to 108191.7
Date: 9/3/2009 2:27:05 PM
Overall Posts Rated:
154154
I think that simplest way to solve it is to give a message if your player is in national team on daily update. If he was not at last update then tell the manager that he is chosen for national team.

I think that the annoyance to users by letting them know that their player was picked and dropped is unnecessary in my opinion.

I think that current system where you can check skills during season break is the best possible. It would be worse if the national coach could see skills for every user during the whole season and it would certainly be worse if you could not see skills for players in the national team.

Another alternative is to give the national team coach full access to every player in the country during off season but I am certainly not favoring that as that would give the national coach a big advantage for their own team.

The suggestion to instead write a note that player was on test training also makes sense to me even if I favor to completely skip a message about chosen in national team if it is for just minutes ...

I think you are solving a thing where nothing to solve.

Annoyance. You can ignore it easily. On the other hand there will certainly be managers which would liek to know their players were scouted.

For your information - national coach can see skills of any player eligiblke for the particular nt/u21 team any time he wants. Enthusiasm management is the obstacle.

You are realizing every player in country doesn't equal to every eligible player and that there are U21 teams, aren't you.

So it is bother you as much as say current news. System doesn't spam you with bb-mails or anything. I guess you just need an ignore button to fell you are ignoring it the right way.)
Let's just say I am not looking forward to the new league news feature flooded...

It won't be flooded. In normal weeks that's not happening at all.