The rookie game is not the all star game, and people who play in it are not labelled as all stars.
No, personally I cannot beat Drew Gooden one on one (although I have yet to try.) I am 5'3" and he would block every shot. That doesn't make him a great player. That's like saying because he can't beat me in a cook-off that I am a world class chef. I assure you, just because I can make a killer mac + cheese, I am not.
Having a roster with current all stars on it is one thing, and having a roster with former all stars is another. Please take some time to grasp that point.
Stop bing less than smart all the time. ;)
If you remember me, then I don't care if everyone else forgets.