His +1 was Grusauskas who has 11 ID. My SF should dominiate him inside like a child.
There were three different defenders on four defended shots. This is a far too small sample. It even doesn't show, that your player was the best chosen shooter from the game engine.
You need a far higher sample than just this one game. Than you can find out, what happened. But one game is just not reliable. If you have a scale from 0 to 100, this game could be at the edge of one side. I ran around 30-50 games per tactic to generate a big enough data overview.