Look at real life in the NBA. Some of the guys that make it dont arguably deserve to be there over some of the players that didnt make it. It happens every year.The All-star selection being the way it is now is fine enough and realistic enough for what im suggesting. It could be refined more but for the developers sake, i dont see it as a high priority issue.
My bad didn't notice you were from D.4, so you probably won't see much of such players anyway.
Furthermore to say a 100k center having enough skill drops to match a non training 20k center is laughable, even though it's for the sake of argument, but please don't make stuff up.